The Times of India has initiated a novel concept called “Lead India” for selecting (or electing?) leaders for the country based on merit and proved achievements. The idea is laudable and the rationale behind it is noble and interesting. A few days ago Jug Suraya wrote some interesting thoughts on this topic in TOI. He says our problem is hardly lack of leaders in sufficient numbers! We have plenty of them but who will follow the leader. That is the crux of the matter. Each of us thinks of ourselves as leaders, and we are prepared to lead but who is to follow?
The problem is that we are averse to follow any rule. Each individual has his own set of rules to follow. We all agree that corruption is the most wide spread disease that is affecting the progress of our country. We have corruption in all walks of life. We condemn corruption in the morning and indulge in it for the rest of the day, either giving or taking bribes! We have a set of rules for others and another for ourselves!
Our lawmakers have enacted “Right to information bill”. One should think that it is a mockery of public intelligence! Why should a bill be enacted to give the public the right to information? Is it not an admission of the secrecy with which the officials conduct the business of the Government? If the activities of the Government are transparent as it should be, where is the need for the Right to information bill? Even after enacting the law the Government and the officials are doing their best to circumvent it by hook or by crook!
Experts have categorised corruption under two general heads: (a) Collusive corruption and (b) Coercive corruption.
Collusive corruption is one in which both the giver and the taker of the bribes or commissions (for example collusion between a contractor and a govt official) stand to gain and the loser is the exchequer. The corruption is not immediately seen or felt by the common man. Generally the common man is indifferent to this kind of corruption.
Coercive corruption is different. The common man is subjected to this kind of corruption in his daily life. The root of the problem lies in the rules that curtail the freedom of the individual. The hundreds and thousands of rules and regulations that control each and every activity of the Government is the cause for this corruption. The rules are made for the ostensible reason of fair conduct of the Government officials and for the benefit of the ordinary citizen. But these rules have become the cause for corruption.
The common citizen’s ignorance of the innumerable rules that come in the way of his freedom to do anything as he or she wishes combined with his propensity to avoid as many rules as possible, makes it a fertile ground for the law enforcer to demand and take bribes!
Many experts in the field of Government administration have been repeatedly advocating scrapping laws, which are irrelevant and retrograde. But who is to act?
Many find it profitable not to follow rules, because enforcing rules is not an easy task, either for government or for social organisations. For example, in our multi-storied apartment building one of the apartment owners stopped paying maintenance charges to the informal Association of the members. For close to eight years he did not pay and the Association could not do anything to recover the dues, except threatening to stop water supply etc and he would say that the Association has no legal rights to cut off his water supply and that he would get a stay order from the court! The law he would say was on his side! Seeing that this man was getting away with his threats at least six others started defaulting in paying the dues and the maintenance of the building suffered. As suggested by a lawyer we got our Association registered under the Society of Firms and sent legal notices to the defaulters and also got a caveat against any stay order from court against stoppage of water and other services. The defaulters soon came round for settlement with the Association, sensing that a prolonged legal battle would not benefit them. Since the Association was a registered body we were obliged to hold Annual General Body Meeting and submit a copy of the minutes to the Registrar of Societies, along with audited copy of financial statement and audit report. When our representative went to the Registrars office to submit the returns, the junior officer talked to him rudely and told him to come another day. On next visit he would point out some mistake and on the next visit he would ask something else. He would be making several visits without any result. And one day he would openly demand for money in order to accept our returns! For the last two years we resisted paying any bribe money and the officers changed the tactics. They said that the Association should give an affidavit. But an affidavit saying what? The officer would not say. All he said was that you ask the dealer (that is one of the touts walking the premises of the office) and soon it became evident that we must pay the bribe! It cost the Association nearly Rs.5000/- to make the officer accept our returns! That is coercive corruption. Who has the time to fight this petty official who probably is in league with others!
Coercive corruption also is well organised. Our complaints fall on deaf ears and one ends up paying bribes. The only way to reduce corruption is to reduce the procedures and rules to the minimum. For example, when you purchase a new apartment you would want the Electric bills to be made in your name. A simple request is not enough for this. You must go to a tout or agent named by the official, and pay a sum of money to get the work done! You buy a property but you cannot pay the taxes unless you pay a bribe! The official will find a hundred reasons for not accepting the payment!
Traffic in our city is chaotic. You see traffic policemen in groups of three or four in junctions making out receipts for the fines or collecting bribes for not booking for the offences committed by the citizens. If these traffic policemen take the trouble of enforcing the traffic rules by directing the traffic there would be no traffic offence committed. But they are busy collecting bribes! One day a couple of friends travelling in a car stopped at the signals waiting for the green light and he was on the front row, waiting. He saw a traffic policeman standing a little distance away scribbling furiously in his little book and his friend told him jokingly that he was sure the policeman was writing down his number. Sure as his friend said the policeman was writing down his car number, and a few days later he got a letter from the police department asking him to pay a fine of Rs.300/- for rash driving! I am sure the policeman could not have been able to write down the car registration number if he was driving rashly as stated in the letter. Obviously the policeman was only making up his quota of fines and he chose the easiest way and jotted down the number of a stationary car! That is the way they work and we are helpless in changing the system.
So ultimately it is not the quality of the leaders that matter but that of the followers!!








This state of affairs continued for many days and we were witness to several fisticuffs in front of our building every day. When the problem became really out of control few of us living in the Apartment approached the traffic dept and gave a written complaint and explained our woes to the head of the dept, who promised to look into the matter. Within less than a week a traffic policeman visited our building and talked to the building management. He said he could arrange to fix “No parking” signs on one side of the road and put on duty one constable to enforce the rules. The problem he said was that there is a great demand for these “No parking” sign-boards and probably he might be able to fix one near our building after 12 to 18 months.